Guest condition reportIndependent · written by a paying guest
⚠ Warning — this unit is a health hazard and the host is negligent, deceptive and fraudulent
1.0Condition

Anywhere On Foot — Big Belgrade Fortress Flat

Cara Uroša 8/13, 11000 Belgrade, Serbia

Owner and host: Nataša

The air conditioner in this apartment is packed with dust and cannot be run. Switch it on and it blows that dust through the rooms you sleep and eat in. Nobody wants to breathe it, and dust loading like this is a well-known respiratory irritant — you don't need a pre-existing condition for it to matter.

So you leave it off. In a Belgrade summer that means no cooling at all — and because a split system is the heating as well, it means the same in winter.

The bathroom smells of sewage. Reported, the answer was that the pipes are "outside of my control" and that I could try pouring boiling water down the drains myself.

She agreed the apartment was unacceptable — and then did nothing. Told the flat had not been cleaned, she replied that it was "unexceptionable" — plainly meaning unacceptable — and apologised. Nothing was done. Told the rest, her position became "Unfortunately, I can't do anything about it" and "in this moment I can only help by listening."

Consider that offer. The person proposing to help by listening was the same person who had let the flat in that condition, declined to clean it, told me to clean it myself, promised money in writing, kept it, and then stopped answering altogether. Being listened to by her was not a remedy — it was the problem, restated as a kindness. What she was asking, in the end, was that I accept it.

Nataša knew about all of it. She was told, she agreed in writing that the filter was the problem, and she still refused to have it cleaned — she told me to wash it myself. She would not let me out of the booking while workmen were drilling and sawing in the common hallway immediately outside the apartment door, through the working day. She promised a refund in writing and did not pay it.

It photographs beautifully. That is not what staying here is like.

Documented 8–11 August 2026 by a guest who paid in full. The unit may since have been cleaned — I have no way to know. Everything below is what was found, when, and what the host said about it in writing.

Four reasons not to book

  1. No working air conditioning — and no working heating

    The filter was matted shut (photographs below, taken 10 August). Asked when it had last been cleaned:

    "A month and a half ago"

    Host, 10 Aug 14:43

    The quantity of dust in those photographs is not what six weeks produces. Asked for it to be cleaned that day:

    "They are fully booked for today … the filter you can rinse under water or vacuum if you think it is causing you allergies."

    Host, 10 Aug 14:52

    That leaves two options, and both are bad. Run it, and it drives that dust into the air of a one-bedroom flat — nobody wants to sleep in that, and heavy dust loading is a recognised respiratory irritant whether or not you arrive with a condition. Or switch it off, which is what I did, and have no cooling in a Belgrade August.

    And this is not only a summer problem. The wall unit is a split system — the same box that cools is the heating. A filter in that state means the apartment has no working climate control in either direction, all year.

  2. Construction right outside the door — and no way out

    Workmen drilled and sawed through the working day in the common hallway immediately outside the apartment door (see the video below). When I said the apartment was unworkable and asked to leave and be refunded, the answer was no.

    "every apartment has a right to be loud" … "Balcan is not set up for remote workers"

    Host, 10 Aug 10:44 and 10:51

    You are not getting released early from this booking, whatever happens in the building.

  3. It was not cleaned before I arrived — and she agreed that was unacceptable

    Uncollected rubbish inside the flat, old pizza and old drinks in the fridge, cigarette ends on the balcony, and a cracked balcony pane.

    "What? I'll tell my housekeeping. That is unexceptionable. They forgot to take it out" … "I apologize"

    Host, 9 Aug 17:39

    Her word is "unexceptionable" — plainly meant as unacceptable. So this is not a dispute about standards. She agreed, in writing and immediately, that the state of the apartment was unacceptable.

    Then nothing happened. The rubbish was still there the next day. When I asked for it to be removed, I was told housekeeping could not come until the following day and that I could leave the pizza box out on the balcony myself — followed by:

    "I wish you told me you want them to take out the trash"

    Host, 10 Aug 14:52

    Having called it unacceptable herself, she did nothing about it and then suggested the problem was that I had not asked clearly enough. What she is actually asking, across the whole exchange, is that you accept it.

  4. A refund was promised in writing and never paid

    She agreed in writing to refund one night. Instead, the following day, the booking record was altered — removing that night, and with it her commission and the city tax on it.

    No money was ever sent. I asked repeatedly — "Did you send money?", "I see no paypal. You said you would send yesterday." She stopped replying altogether.

    See the financial record →

  5. The internet does not work — and the prescribed fix is to keep rebooting the router

    The listing advertises free WiFi. It never once completed a speed test. Pages took around twenty seconds to load and a voice call could not stay connected. Reported to the host, her remedy was this:

    "Unplug it from the socket and plug it back in"

    Host, 9 Aug 21:58

    It made no difference. The next morning I reported it was still failing, and this was as far as it went:

    "Let me call the company and see what the problem is" … "I checked with the internet company. Unfortunately, they gave a very generic answer. They are experiencing technical difficulties, and they are working on it. I asked for a time frame but they didn't say when it will be better"

    Host, 10 Aug 09:29 and 09:59

    Unplug-and-replug is what you tell someone about a router you have never touched and do not intend to. Nobody came, nothing was fixed, and I never had usable internet for the length of the stay.

Photographs

Air-conditioning filter almost entirely occluded by a thick grey mat of dust and lint
The A/C filter as found10 Aug 2026 · 14:39:08
Second close view of the same filter, mesh completely blocked by dust
Same filter, second view10 Aug 2026 · 14:39:14
Wall-mounted VIVAX split-system air conditioner in the apartment
The unit — VIVAX split system10 Aug 2026 · 14:37:28
Bag of rubbish and cigarette ends left on the balcony at check-in
On the balcony at check-in9 Aug 2026 · 17:34:17
Old pizza box and old drinks left in the refrigerator at check-in
In the fridge on arrival9 Aug 2026 · 17:29:52
Cracked pane of glass on the apartment balcony
Cracked balcony pane9 Aug 2026 · 17:40:00

On the timestamps. Each photograph's camera clock falls within minutes of the message reporting that problem to the host — fridge and cigarettes at 17:29 and 17:34 against a 17:36 message; the filter at 14:39 against a 14:41 message. They were taken as things were found, not assembled afterwards. The original files retain the metadata.

Video

The advertised "free WiFi" — a single page loading, recorded in the apartment.
Workmen in the common hallway immediately outside the apartment door, recorded 11 August 2026.

The same apartment, under two names

If you are comparing places in Belgrade, check the photographs on these listings against the ones above before you book.

PlatformListed as
Booking.comAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free ParkingListing
AirbnbAnywhere on Foot – FREE Parking (Stari grad)Listing

Reported to

BodyGroundsStatus
Booking.comHealth and safety; alteration of the booking recordOpen
Airbnb — safety reportAir-conditioning maintenance, same unitOpen
Turistička inspekcija
Ministarstvo turizma i omladine
Condition and maintenance of a categorised unit; guest registration; residence taxOpen
Sanitarna inspekcija
Ministarstvo zdravlja
Hygiene of air-conditioning and plumbing in a unit let to the publicOpen
Poreska upravaDeclared income and residence tax on the altered nightOpen

Accuracy and right of reply. Every quotation here is verbatim from written correspondence, and every figure comes from Booking.com's own invoice and system emails. This page states no claim I cannot document. If anything is shown to be inaccurate I will correct it and say on this page that I have. The host is welcome to reply and I will publish her response alongside this.

Rahul Lio

Guest, 8–11 August 2026

Everywhere this apartment is sold

The same 60 m² flat at Cara Uroša 8/13 is resold under slightly different names across a dozen booking sites. If you are comparing places in Belgrade, check the photographs on any of these against the ones above before you book.

PlatformListed asRating shown
Booking.comAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free Parking9.8 (5)Listing
AirbnbAnywhere on Foot – FREE Parking4.5 (8)Listing
AgodaAnywhere On Foot - Belgrade FortressListing
Bedandbreakfast.euAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat10 (3)Listing
SkyscannerAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free ParkingListing

Why the ratings look good. Each platform shows a handful of reviews — five here, three there, eight on another. A property spread thinly across many sites never accumulates enough reviews on any one of them for a bad stay to move the number. That is what you are looking at when you see 9.8 out of 5 reviews.

Contact me

If you stayed here, if you are deciding whether to book, or if you are the host and want to reply — write to me. I answer everything.

⚠ Upozorenje — ovaj stan je opasan po zdravlje, a domaćica je nemarna, obmanjuje goste i vara
1.0Stanje

Anywhere On Foot — Big Belgrade Fortress Flat

Cara Uroša 8/13, 11000 Beograd, Srbija

Vlasnica i domaćica: Nataša

Klima uređaj u ovom stanu pun je prašine i ne može da se koristi. Kada ga uključite, tu prašinu razvejava po prostorijama u kojima spavate i jedete. Niko to ne želi da udiše, a ovoliko nataložena prašina poznat je iritant disajnih puteva — nije potrebno da imate ranije tegobe da bi vam smetalo.

Znači, držite je isključenu. Usred beogradskog leta to znači da hlađenja nema uopšte — a pošto isti split uređaj služi i za grejanje, isto važi i zimi.

Iz kupatila se oseća kanalizacija. Na prijavu je odgovoreno da su cevi „van moje kontrole" i da mogu da probam da sam sipam ključalu vodu u odvode.

Složila se da je stan u nedopustivom stanju — a zatim nije uradila ništa. Kada sam prijavio da stan nije očišćen, odgovorila je da je to „unexceptionable" — očigledno u značenju nedopustivo — i izvinila se. Ništa nije preduzeto. Za sve ostalo njen stav je postao „Nažalost, ne mogu ništa da uradim po tom pitanju" i „u ovom trenutku mogu da pomognem samo tako što ću vas saslušati."

Razmislite o toj ponudi. Osoba koja nudi pomoć time što će vas saslušati jeste ista ona koja je stan izdala u takvom stanju, odbila da ga očisti, rekla meni da ga sam čistim, pismeno obećala novac, zadržala ga, a zatim potpuno prestala da odgovara. To što vas ona sasluša nije lek — to je isti problem, samo predstavljen kao ljubaznost. Ono što je na kraju tražila jeste — da to prihvatim.

Nataša je za sve to znala. Bila je obaveštena, pismeno se složila da je filter uzrok, i svejedno odbila da ga očisti — rekla mi je da ga sam operem. Nije htela da me pusti iz rezervacije dok su radnici ceo radni dan bušili i sekli u zajedničkom hodniku neposredno ispred vrata stana. Pismeno je obećala povraćaj novca i nije ga isplatila.

Na fotografijama izgleda odlično. Boravak nije takav.

Dokumentovano 8–11. avgusta 2026. od strane gosta koji je platio u celosti. Apartman je u međuvremenu možda očišćen — to ne mogu znati. Sve ispod je ono što je zatečeno, kada je zatečeno i šta je domaćica o tome pismeno rekla.

Četiri razloga da ne rezervišete

  1. Nema ispravnog hlađenja — ni grejanja

    Filter je bio potpuno zapušen (fotografije ispod, snimljene 10. avgusta). Na pitanje kada je poslednji put čišćen:

    „Pre mesec i po dana"

    Domaćica, 10. avg 14.43

    Količina prašine na tim fotografijama ne odgovara šest nedelja. Na traženje da se očisti istog dana:

    „Danas su potpuno zauzeti… filter možete isprati vodom ili usisati ako mislite da vam izaziva alergiju."

    Domaćica, 10. avg 14.52

    Ostaju dve mogućnosti i obe su loše. Uključiti je — i tu prašinu razvejati po jednosobnom stanu; niko ne želi da spava u tome, a ovoliko nataložena prašina priznat je iritant disajnih puteva bez obzira na to da li ste došli sa tegobama. Ili je držati isključenu, što sam i radio, i ostati bez hlađenja usred beogradskog avgusta.

    A ovo nije samo letnji problem. Zidni uređaj je split sistem — ista jedinica koja hladi služi i za grejanje. Filter u ovakvom stanju znači da stan nema ispravnu klimatizaciju ni u jednom smeru, tokom cele godine.

  2. Radovi tik ispred vrata — i nemogućnost izlaska

    Radnici su ceo radni dan bušili i sekli u zajedničkom hodniku neposredno ispred vrata stana (videti snimak ispod). Kada sam rekao da se u stanu ne može boraviti ni raditi i tražio da odem i dobijem novac nazad, odgovor je bio ne.

    „svaki stan ima pravo da bude bučan" … „Balkan nije prilagođen ljudima koji rade od kuće"

    Domaćica, 10. avg 10.44 i 10.51

    Iz ove rezervacije nećete izaći ranije, šta god da se dešava u zgradi.

  3. Stan nije bio očišćen pre mog dolaska — i sama je rekla da je to nedopustivo

    Neodneto smeće u stanu, stara pica i stara pića u frižideru, opušci na terasi i napuklo staklo na terasi.

    „Molim? Reći ću spremačici. To je unexceptionable. Zaboravili su da ga iznesu" … „Izvinjavam se"

    Domaćica, 9. avg 17.39 — original na engleskom

    Reč koju je upotrebila je „unexceptionable", očigledno u značenju unacceptable — nedopustivo. Dakle, ovde nema spora oko standarda. Pismeno je i odmah priznala da je stanje stana nedopustivo.

    A zatim se ništa nije dogodilo. Smeće je i sutradan bilo tu. Kada sam tražio da se iznese, rečeno mi je da spremačica ne može doći pre narednog dana i da kutiju od pice mogu sam da ostavim na terasi — uz:

    „Voleo bih da ste mi rekli da želite da iznesu smeće"

    Domaćica, 10. avg 14.52

    Pošto je i sama to nazvala nedopustivim, ništa nije preduzela, a zatim je sugerisala da je problem u tome što nisam dovoljno jasno tražio. Ono što u celoj prepisci zapravo traži jeste — da to prihvatite.

  4. Povraćaj novca pismeno obećan, nikada isplaćen

    Pismeno je pristala da vrati iznos za jedno noćenje. Umesto toga je narednog dana izmenjena evidencija rezervacije — uklonjeno je to noćenje, a sa njim i njena provizija i boravišna taksa za tu noć.

    Novac nikada nije poslat. Pitao sam više puta — „Da li ste poslali novac?", „Ne vidim ništa na PayPal-u. Rekli ste da ćete poslati juče." Prestala je da odgovara.

    Finansijska dokumentacija →

  5. Internet ne radi — a propisan lek je da stalno restartujete ruter

    Oglas nudi besplatan WiFi. Nijednom nije uspeo da završi test brzine. Stranice su se učitavale oko dvadeset sekundi, a govorni poziv nije mogao da ostane povezan. Kada sam prijavio, njen lek je bio ovaj:

    „Isključite ga iz utičnice i ponovo uključite"

    Domaćica, 9. avg 21.58

    Nije pomoglo. Sledećeg jutra sam prijavio da i dalje ne radi, i ovo je sve što se dogodilo:

    „Da pozovem kompaniju i vidim u čemu je problem" … „Proverila sam kod provajdera interneta. Nažalost, dobila sam veoma uopšten odgovor. Imaju tehničkih poteškoća i rade na tome. Tražila sam rok, ali nisu rekli kada će biti bolje"

    Domaćica, 10. avg 09.29 i 09.59

    Isključi-pa-uključi je ono što kažete nekome o ruteru koji nikada niste dotakli i ne nameravate da dotaknete. Niko nije došao, ništa nije popravljeno, i internet nije postao upotrebljiv za ceo boravak.

Fotografije

Filter klima uređaja gotovo potpuno zatvoren debelim slojem sive prašine
Filter klime kako je zatečen10. avg 2026 · 14.39.08
Drugi snimak istog filtera, mrežica potpuno zapušena
Isti filter, drugi ugao10. avg 2026 · 14.39.14
Zidni VIVAX klima uređaj u apartmanu
Sam uređaj — VIVAX10. avg 2026 · 14.37.28
Kesa sa smećem i opušci na terasi pri useljenju
Na terasi pri useljenju9. avg 2026 · 17.34.17
Stara kutija od pice i pića u frižideru pri useljenju
U frižideru po dolasku9. avg 2026 · 17.29.52
Napuklo staklo na terasi
Napuklo staklo na terasi9. avg 2026 · 17.40.00

O vremenskim oznakama. Sat aparata na svakoj fotografiji pada u razmak od nekoliko minuta od poruke kojom je taj problem prijavljen domaćici — frižider i opušci u 17.29 i 17.34 naspram poruke u 17.36; filter u 14.39 naspram poruke u 14.41. Snimane su kako su stvari zaticane, a ne sastavljane naknadno. Originalni fajlovi čuvaju metapodatke.

Snimci

Oglašeni „besplatan WiFi" — učitavanje jedne stranice, snimljeno u stanu.
Radnici u zajedničkom hodniku neposredno ispred vrata stana, snimljeno 11. avgusta 2026.

Isti apartman pod dva naziva

Ako upoređujete smeštaj u Beogradu, uporedite fotografije sa ovih oglasa sa gornjima pre nego što rezervišete.

PlatformaNaziv oglasa
Booking.comAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free ParkingOglas
AirbnbAnywhere on Foot – FREE Parking (Stari grad)Oglas

Prijavljeno

Organ / platformaOsnovStatus
Booking.comZdravlje i bezbednost; izmena evidencije rezervacijeU toku
Airbnb — prijava bezbednostiOdržavanje klima uređaja, isti apartmanU toku
Turistička inspekcija
Ministarstvo turizma i omladine
Stanje i održavanje kategorisanog objekta; evidentiranje gosta; boravišna taksaU toku
Sanitarna inspekcija
Ministarstvo zdravlja
Higijena klima uređaja i vodovoda u objektu koji se izdaje gostimaU toku
Poreska upravaPrijavljeni prihod i boravišna taksa za izmenjeno noćenjeU toku

Tačnost i pravo na odgovor. Svaki citat je doslovno prenet iz pisane prepiske, a svaki iznos potiče iz računa i sistemskih poruka samog Booking.com-a. Stranica ne iznosi nijednu tvrdnju koju ne mogu da dokumentujem. Ako se pokaže da je nešto netačno, ispraviću i to na ovoj stranici navesti. Domaćica ima pravo na odgovor i objaviću ga uz ovaj tekst.

Rahul Lio

Gost, 8–11. avgusta 2026.

Svuda gde se ovaj stan prodaje

Isti stan od 60 m² u Cara Uroša 8/13 preprodaje se pod neznatno različitim nazivima na desetak sajtova za rezervacije. Ako upoređujete smeštaj u Beogradu, uporedite fotografije sa bilo kog od njih sa gornjima pre nego što rezervišete.

PlatformaNaziv oglasaPrikazana ocena
Booking.comAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free Parking9,8 (5)Oglas
AirbnbAnywhere on Foot – FREE Parking4,5 (8)Oglas
AgodaAnywhere On Foot - Belgrade FortressOglas
Bedandbreakfast.euAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat10 (3)Oglas
SkyscannerAnywhere On Foot – Big Belgrade Fortress Flat – Free ParkingOglas

Zašto ocene izgledaju dobro. Svaka platforma prikazuje po nekoliko recenzija — pet ovde, tri tamo, osam na trećoj. Objekat raspoređen na mnogo sajtova nikada ni na jednom ne skupi dovoljno recenzija da bi jedan loš boravak pomerio ocenu. To je ono što vidite kada piše 9,8 na osnovu pet recenzija.

Kontaktirajte me

Ako ste boravili u ovom stanu, ako se dvoumite oko rezervacije, ili ako ste domaćica i želite da odgovorite — pišite mi. Odgovaram na sve.